Start
About Nordic
The issues
Publications
Contact
Search
Subscribe
Feedback
Printer friendly

Noise Reducing Pavements
– Internationally!


The latest international experiences are presented. Good noise reduction and durability as well as good friction have been achieved in Europe.


There is an increasing focus in Denmark on the possibilities of using thin layer pavements, which have been optimised to reduce noise. The Danish Road Directorate/ Danish Road Institute (DRI) has published two new reports about international experiences with noise reducing thin layer pavements based on literature studies and visits to France and USA. The purpose was to obtain the latest international knowledge, which can form the background for a continued development and optimisation of noise reducing properties and durability of thin layer pavements in Holland and Denmark.
The work has been carried out within the framework of the co-operation on research and development, which DRI is carrying out with Road and Hydraulic Engineering Institute (DWW) in the Netherlands in the period from 2004 –2007, called the “DRI-DWW noise abatement programme” [1].
Thin layer pavements were introduced in the early 1990s and have since been used in France and other European countries on a large scale. The purpose was to obtain good friction at a relatively low price. In the late 1990s, work was started to modify these pavements to also obtain noise reductions. France also has worked on optimising the pavements to obtain noise-reducing qualities, not only on urban roads, but also on rural roads and motorways. This work has changed existing mix designs, which can have consequences on the durability, friction and other relevant properties.
Use of thin layer pavements is not new in Denmark either, but the new aspect is that the pavements are being optimised in order to obtain



better noise reducing properties.
There are two important mechanisms which influence the amount of tyre-road surface noise:
• Noise from the vibration of tyres is generated by the contact between the rubber blocks on the surface of the tyre and the surface of the road. These vibrations start moving the air surrounding the tyre, which




Microphone on roadside to measure noise.

then creates noise. This noise is in the frequency area less than 1000 Hz. The more even the road pavement, the less noise.
• Noise from air pumping occurs when a tyre goes over a pavement. As the rubber blocks of the tyre hit the road surface, they are compressed, and thus the air between the rubber blocks is pushed out. When the rubber blocks are released from the road surface, air is sucked in again. These quick movements in the air result in high frequency noise over 1000 Hz. If the road pavement has an open structure the air will to a greater extent be pressed into the pavement and be sucked up again, which reduces the level of noise produced.

When comparing noise levels, it is always necessary to have a reference pavement against which the noise level can be compared. The layer thickness has in fact no direct influence on the noise level from noise reducing pavements. But as mentioned above, there is an indirect effect by using a little maximum aggregate size of 6 or 8 mm. Since as a rule of thumb, pavements usually are constructed three times the size of the aggregate in thickness, noise reducing pavements with an open structure will usually have a small layer thickness of typically 15-25 mm. This can give a noise reducing effect. However, not all thin pavements are noise-reducing.

Noise reduction
In France, researchers and asphalt producers have worked for a number of years to develop noise reducing thin layer pavements. Thin pavements are divided into two classes depending on the voids in the pavement mix. They have a thickness of 20-30 mm. Also a type of ultra thin pavement is being considered with a thickness of 15-20 mm. In order to obtain an efficient sealing, an emulsion layer is usually put underneath the thin pavement. Modified bitumen is used in places where there is a risk of shear forces. According to the French Road

Research Laboratory, LCPC, thin pavements are resistant to rutting, they reduce splashing from rain and have a high friction. It would seem  that pavements with 6 mm aggregate have a better friction than pavements with 10 mm aggregate.
Noise reductions were measured in France in relation to a dense asphalt concrete with 10 mm maximum aggregate size, which basically corresponds to the Danish reference pavement. Noise is measured at 80 km/h and 90 km/h. In general, noise reductions are measured on thin layer pavements of 2-4 dB, which is less than can obtained on a drainage asphalt, which is 4-6 dB. It can be seen that the best noise reduction can be obtained on pavements with the smallest aggregate and for Class 2 pavements with the largest possible voids. The noise reduction is in general somewhat greater for cars than lorries.

Hans Bendtsen

Literature:
1. The DRI-DWW Noise Abatement Programme —Project description. Technical Note 24, 2005.
Danish Road Directorate, Danish Road Institute
2. International experiences with thin Iayer pavements.
Technical Note 29, 2005. Danish Road Directorate, Danish Road institute
3. French experience on noise reducing thin Iayer.
Technical Note 28, 2005. Danish Road Directorate, Danish Road Institute

Article specially written for Nordic Road & Transport Research by Senior Researcher Hans Bendtsen, Road Directorate Danish Road Institute
hbe@vd.dk.




Content
Nordic NO.2 2006
In Brief
Atumn Brings Darker Conditions
New Manual for Road and Street Design
Harmonisation of Road Signs and Marking
Rumble Strips Make Rural Roads Safer
Improved Road Safety in Kungsbacka Town Centre
Traffic Safety on Wind-exposed Roads in Iceland
Designing the Urban Motorring 3
Environmental Aspects of the Bjoervika Project in Oslo
2005 Norwegian Travel Survey
Under-sea Tunnels: New World Record
Fire in Tunnels: The Runehamar Test Tunnel
SUNflower – Developments in Traffic Safety in Sweden, the UK and the Netherlands
Vibrations on Trains Disturb Passenger Activities
Motorring 10 and Noise Reducing Pavements
Noise Reducing Pavements– Internationally!
Recycling of Oil Installation
Annotated Reports